Weight Training? Go Light!

It's a time-honored debate, and the decision over whether to “lift heavy” or “lift light” has started even more tavern arguments than “treadmill or elliptical?”

The consensus, or perhaps popular mythology, has been that if you wanted to really sculpt and chisel your body – put on a massive amount of muscle – you needed to lift really heavy weights. Conversely, if all you wanted was to be “toned,” lifting light weights was the way to go. After all, have you ever met one of the really ripped guys who wasn't routinely bench-pressing hundreds of pounds as part of his regular exercise regimen?

A brand new study out of McMaster University in Ontario, Canada turns conventional wisdom on its head.

The key to muscle gain, say the researchers, is working to the point of fatigue.

“We found that loads that were quite heavy and comparatively light were equally effective at inducing muscle growth and promoting strength,” says Cam Mitchell, one of the lead authors of the study and a Ph.D candidate in the Department of Kinesiology.

The research, published in the Journal of Applied Physiology, challenges the widely accepted dogma that training with heavy weights— defined in the study as those which can be lifted only six to 12 times before fatigue — is the best avenue to muscle growth.

“Many older adults can have joint problems which would prevent them training with heavy loads,” says Mitchell.  “This study shows that they have the option of training with lighter and less intimidating loads and can still receive the benefits.”

For the study, a series of experiments were conducted on healthy, young male volunteers to measure how their leg muscles reacted to different forms of resistance training over a period of 10 weeks.  

The researchers first determined the maximum weight each subject could lift one time in a knee extension.  Each subject was assigned to a different training program for each leg.

In all, three different programs were used in combinations that required the volunteers to complete sets of as many repetitions as possible with their assigned loads – typically eight to 12 times per set at the heaviest weights and 25-30 times at the lowest weights.

The three programs used in the combinations were:

- one set at 80 percent of the maximum load

- three sets at 80 percent of the maximum

- three sets at 30 percent of the maximum

After 10 weeks of training, three times per week, the heavy and light groups that lifted three sets saw significant gains in muscle volume — as measured by MRI — with no difference among the groups.  Still, the group that used heavier weights for three sets developed a bit more strength.

The group that trained for a single set showed approximately half the increase in muscle size seen in both the heavy and light groups.

“The complexity of current resistance training guidelines may deter some people from resistance training and therefore from receiving the associated health benefits,” says Stuart Phillips, a professor in the Department of Kinesiology and supervisor of the study.  “Our study provides evidence for a simpler paradigm, where a much broader range of loads including quite light loads can induce muscle growth, provided it is lifted to the point where it is difficult to maintain good form.”